At the urging of local vacation rental companies, Orange Beach passed an ordinance to counter new rules by internet-based companies like Airbnb they say will ignore local safety rules companies must …
This item is available in full to subscribers.
Please log in to continue |
At the urging of local vacation rental companies, Orange Beach passed an ordinance to counter new rules by internet-based companies like Airbnb they say will ignore local safety rules companies must follow by omitting critical information on renters.
Gulf Shores will consider a similar ordinance to make the rules islandwide at its regular session on Nov. 23 at 4 p.m.
“There are several concerns, but allowing a third party to have anonymity where a licensed real estate company is held to strict operating practices is where I draw the line,” Orange Beach Councilman Robert Stuart said. “Also, not allowing the rental manager or the POA to know who the guest is and access to their address, phone number and email address is not acceptable.”
Before retiring and selling his business in June, Stuart was an owner/operator at Sugar Sands Vacation Rentals in Orange Beach.
Councilman Pat Simpson is also a former owner of a vacation rental business.
Orange Beach suspended the rules to pass the ordinance 5-0, with Councilmember Ginger Harrelson absent.
Harrelson, who owns the vacation rental company Beachball Properties with her husband, Hunter Harrelson, who was recently appointed by council to the board of directors of Gulf Shores and Orange Beach Tourism, a government tourism agency funded by the collection of lodging taxes, though out of town, said she would have abstained from voting on the issue.
Beachball Marketing Director Brandy Davis released a statement prior to the recent meetings urging both city councils to support the ordinance changes.
“Local hosts and property rights organizations have raised concerns about the proposal,” Airbnb Communications Manager Jessica King-Garcia said in a press release statement. “They include a conflict of interest: a sitting council member advocating for the changes owns a property management company that stands to benefit.”
King-Garcia said the ordinances would be redundant to rules Airbnb says are already in place.
“These proposed requirements are duplicative and would add unnecessary complications for hosts along the Alabama coast,” she wrote.
Taylor Means, of Bella Beach Properties and a supporter of the ordinance, said during the Gulf Shores Nov. 9 meeting that Airbnb is cutting back on the information management companies have regularly received.
“We’re not asking for the rules to be changed,” he said. “We want to keep the rules the way they’ve always been. I think that’s what this measure does.”
Gulf Shores discussed the issue at length at its Nov. 16 work session meeting.
“Recently, online booking platforms have implemented policies that limit the ability of property owners and management companies to require renters to execute separate written rental agreements unless such agreements are specifically required by local law,” a memo from Gulf Shores Economic Coordinator Blake Phelps states. “As a result, many local operators have expressed concern that the absence of a written rental agreement could impair their ability to utilize existing provisions of the code of ordinances designed to address problem guests and protect neighboring property owners and visitors.”
Phelps’ memo spelled out proposed criteria to add to the ordinance to assuage local concerns.
“Approval of this amendment will help ensure that local property owners, management companies and law enforcement agencies retain the tools necessary to address nuisance behavior, protect public safety and maintain the quality of life for residents and visitors while adapting local regulations to changing online booking platform policies,” Phelps’ memo said.
Essential points of the ordinance amendment are:
“Without ID, owners have no protection against fraud, theft or damage,” Brandy Davis of Beachball Properties said. “Without contact information, managers can't reach guests in an emergency or an evacuation.”
At the Nov. 9 meeting in Gulf Shores, Kelly McFarland of Celebrity Vacation Rentals asked Gulf Shores to enact similar guidelines as Orange Beach to make protections for rental companies islandwide.
“We want to protect our guests’ safety and property owners in our community, accountability for damages and unauthorized guests and guests who refuse to follow the rules,” McFarland said. “Airbnb will restrict property managers from requiring guests from signing separate agreements unless an exception applies. We are already receiving some pushback from this platform.”